Toole, who died in 1996, was officially named the murderer of Adam Walsh in 2008, and the Hollywood Police Department formally closed the Walsh case. At the mere age of 3, Bundys idea of fun was to surround his sleeping stepsister with kitchen knives, waiting for her to wake up, delighting in her terror with an arctic grin. When he was delivered by buggy from the jail in the mornings, he came in whistling a jaunty tune. Duval County, known for years as Florida's murder capital, also leads the state in kids who kill. Two days later, on Aug. 26, 1990,Christa Hoyt was found raped, stabbed and decapitated. They told News4JAX Jackson had just celebrated her 31st birthday on July 21, the day before she was shot to death inside a home on Prospect Street. III cant stand it!. These murders resulted in a delay riot that quickly garnered media attention across the country. He began telling stories, but after a while, the stories themselves took over. Detectives describe the victim as Native-American, 25 to 35 years old and approximately 4 feet and 10 inches to 5 feet, 4 inches tall. The following month, he landed in Jacksonville, where he abducted, raped and murdered 12-year-old Kimberly Leach. Despite representing himself at trial with an almost flamboyant cockiness, Bundy was found guilty and sentenced to death, a sentence that was carried out in Floridas electric chair on January 24, 1989. Wells was strangling him. The girls mother said, decades later, that shed consistently seen a psychiatrist, that Ive had spells in which I go inside myself and dont come out., Elizabeth said her husband Jack, who later suffered heart attacks and strokes following years of depression, insisted the family never move or change their phone number, because, in her words, Daddy thought the babies were coming home.. Toole had an abusive mother whom he claimed would force him to dress in women's clothing while she called him Susan. His maternal grandmother called him the Devil's Child, probably due to his epilepsy and sexual orientation. There, he met a fellow drifter named Henry Lee Lucas at a soup kitchen. Read more about that case here. Fearing for her life, McVey tried to appeal to her kidnappers egoand the speck of humanity she hoped he had. After all, Yavitz never wrote the book Knowles expected. Their rituals required having sex with the dead. Knowless confessions on audio tapes he sent to Yavitz included his story of killing two little girls who saw him ditch a car in the wooded neighborhood of Pumpkin Hill where Mylette and Lillian lived. Eventually, they all ended in conviction for murder due to an anonymous tip that was later revealed to be his half-brother, Philip Brolin. Even as late as the 1990s, the last time such numbers were made public, Duval County had an almost 50 percent functional illiteracy rate. The jury deliberated for about an hour before they inexplicably found J.J. Mendenhall not guilty. Another remarkable serial killer, Oscar Ray Bolin Jr., aka Bolin the Butcher, was convicted of stabbing and beating three Florida women and sentenced to death twice. Falling remains in prison. When the jurors returned to the courtroom, the place was packed with spectators, among whom, the newspapers reported, were the usual number of ladies.. It was only one day after that when Rolling killed two more UF students: roommates Tracy Paules and Manuel Taboada. Gerard Schaefer was dubbed the "Killer Cop" because he was a Sheriff's deputy who found his victims while on patrol in Martin County, Florida. Everyone saw him as strange. The detectives were called to bring the gun into court, but couldnt find it in the property room where it had been stored. Her youngest child, Shelton, only four months old at the time his mother was murdered, was asking for some answers. Their bodies were found mutilated. But when you give consideration to the other factors, the legal factors, as well as the wishes of the family, and the offer to plead guilty and to have the case disposed of very, very quickly.. Every inmate death is thoroughly investigated by law enforcement and the Departments Office of Inspector General to ensure independent oversight and absolute accountability at all levels.. In between, there were victims in Maryland, Georgia and Florida. Bludgeoning, garroting and sexually assaulting the young women left him unsated, and shortly after leaving the house, he broke into a nearby apartment and attacked another FSU student with such brutality that her injuries resulted in lifelong disabilities. Bundy got off on inflicting grievous injury upon his victims, whom he raped beforeand sometimes afterdeath. The Anderson girls mother left them alone for less than an hour, expecting her husband home soon from work. BUSH, Oba The crime earned him five consecutive life sentences. Yes. ANDERSON, John Earl Others said they recognized his shadow or his way of moving in the dark. Domingo Herrera was not with them. She would later claim that Mallory sodomized and tortured her, promising that her death was imminent, before she pulled a handgun from her purse, shot him to death and then robbed him. John Walsh is most famous for hosting Americas Most Wanted and for his advocacy for missing children. Sue grew hysterical, pulled a pistol from Mendenhalls pocket, and aimed it at him. He was apprehended in 1991 and executed in 2006 at the age of 52 by lethal injection. Prosecuting attorneys insisted on the similarity between this double-murder and the one that had sent him to jail years ago, while the defense argued that the similarity was the reason the murder had been pegged on Mendenhall in the first place. She often wondered why Knowles hadnt murdered her. Meanwhile, Jack Anderson, the father of Mylette and Lillian Annete, waited for his daughters phone call every night for 20 years. Which way did you go on the turnpike, north or south? RAULERSON, Anthony The couple said they did their research, but there's . JaxPsychoGeo stories take a lot of work. She soon realized she was alone with a lone stranger. A 1933 Literary Digest article titled The High Murder Rate in the South again pointed to Jacksonville at the top, and included among contributing factors leniency toward pistol toters, the vestigial remains of an old chivalry which demands blood for violation of [] honor and the primitive passions of the Negro population.. He was subsequently convicted of beating a cellmate to death in 2011. But Willie Jr. couldnt help but look. He said he only kept the profits of the sale of the house Mary Rae and her mother deeded to him because Mary Rae had insisted he do so against his own inclinations. More details about Martinez can be found here. Nelsons role became an issue in her 2016 election when then-incumbent State Attorney Angela Corey criticized her for not seeking the death penalty. Odd, she thought, as the car then pulled into a church parking lot and idled. Mendenhall said he and Mary Rae had planned to get married. All of the cases were posted by . The ruined Citrus King was a pitiful wreck of a man. Legal in his TV ads, a doobie-rolling, guitar-strumming troubadour who mounted an incompetent and self-serving representation of Aileen. Bowles was recently executed in Florida for killing Walter Hinton in Jacksonville Beach in 1994. Only one other county has more: Miami-Dade, which has nearly three times the youth population. Youre digging yourself a hole, Ottis, and youre not gonna get out of it. Their statement notes, The safe and secure operation of Floridas correctional institutions is the Department of Corrections top priority. The killing spree in Truman Capotes famous non-fiction novel In Cold Blood began in the woods at the edge of town. Sonja Larson, 18, and Christina Powell, 17, were the first two victims. The odds are that you've heard of these killers but probably didn't know they were from Florida. The other three men went free.
Notorious Criminals and Crimes - ThoughtCo Calvary Baptist Church, Spruce and Dora Streets, Brooklyn: Myrtle Avenue Underpass / Tunnel / Subway, Brooklyn: Pappas Building / H.C. Hare Co. Building, Brooklyn: Reggie Bridgess House / WATG Radio / Unofficial Brooklyn Museum, Cathedral District: The Bodies in Billy Goat Hill, Chamblins Uptown: Gus and Company Building, Chamblins Uptown: The Steel Vault Biography Room, Church of the Immaculate Conception (Oh Sister Mary Ann! I suspect most current middle-class Springfield residents could hardly imagine what the neighborhood was in the 1980s, and most 1980s Springfielders could barely imagine the Springfield of the 1970s and 1960s. After being confronted with the evidence, Long confessed, not only to the Tampa serial murders but also to a series of assaults in South Florida in which he would respond to classified ads and then rape the women he found home alone. Wells alleged accomplice, Leo Boatman, was previously convicted of murdering two Santa Fe College students with an AK-47 while they were camping in the Ocala National Forest in 2006. Jacksonville is safer than 9% of the cities in the United States. You know what youre doing. As his appetite grew more insatiable, his m.o. In fact, it wasnt until they had inquired about the case that the police department even began an investigation. It was around 2 a.m. on November 3, 1984. Photo Credit: Alchetron. Did you plan on going back home?, All right. Newspapers wrote the trial up big. Profiles of Notorious Male Criminals. Patient Experience. While in custody, he also provided information that implicated him of killingJulie Grissom, 24, her nephew Sean Grissom, 8, and her father, Tom Grissom, 55, in Shreveport, Louisiana. Anyone who has any information about this case, the identity, or location of the suspect (s) is asked to contact the Jacksonville Sheriff`s Office at 904-630-0500 or email them at JSOCrimeTips@jaxsheriff.org. Pete Wrights Buried-Alive Bride, Moonshine, and the Rainbow Restaurant, Cleveland Heights: Cleveland Road at Lockhart Drive, Coca-Cola Bottling Company (New Springfield), Durkee Field / J.P. (Bubbling) Small Stadium, Durkeeville: Fairfax Street Wood Treaters / Howard Feed Mills / American Motors Export Company, Durkeeville: Kennelly Building; Ballot Cures, Black Votes Matter, Red Ball Building Goes Blue, Evergreen Cemetery: Muslim Burials and the Founder of the City, Fairview Peninsula at Trout River: Rusted Wrought-Iron Leafwork and Blooms, Harriet Avenue, Fort George Island: Neff House and Betz Sphere, Fort George Island: Neff House Witch Project, Fort George Island: Sandollar Restaurant and Marina, Gateway Mall and Shopping Center / Yellow Fever Burials / Sand Hills Hospital, Harbor View: What Ever Happened to Beverly June? She also makes art, jewelry, and other things for her shop, The Gilded Gator . On the night of the womens deaths, Mendenhall had his chauffer drive the three of them out from town into the hot, humid night. Now Ottis wasnt really sure what he was supposed to answer. One young woman who showed her approval of the verdict by clapping her hands was brought before the judge, where she became the last of at least four people at the trial of Edward Pitzer to collapse in a dead faint. In my nonfiction novel, Stalking Ottis Toole: A Southern Gothic, I try to bounce all the different Ottis Tooles off each other, but I also indicate that, whoever Ottis Toole really was, he didnt have to end up that way. They cant hang him! The strippers, who were nabbed late last night and early this morning, worked at seven Tampa-area clubs: Lollipops; Calendar Girls; Vegas Showgirls; Brass Flamingo; Bare Assets; Foxy Lady; and Club. To the surprise of investigators, lab results from the McVey kidnapping revealed the same unique red fibers, connecting her abduction to the previous murders. Audio Article. Hinton was Bowles' sixth victim in the killing spree that began in Daytona Beach with the slaying of John Hardy Roberts. Then hed say all his murder charges were results of the police playing mind games. ALSTON, Charles L.
Living in a murder house: Central Florida's infamous homicide scenes In May 2000, two more girls were discovered in a second metal drum. She said it made her skin stay young., In Ottiss May 1984 arson murder trial, psychiatrist Eduardo Sanchez said Ottis functions on a very primitive level, almost like a child.
Uncovered: Unsolved Florida Murders It made him significant for the first time in his life. But the state has long beckoned as a lands end for wrongdoers and creeps, and among Floridas dubious distinctions is that the state has churned out an unenviable assortment of some of the nations most notorious serial murders. He even oversaw installment of the first electric chair in Florida in 1924 and was credited with nicknaming it Old Sparky, a moniker thats lasted almost a century.
The Horrifying Crime Spree Of Paul John Knowles, The "Casanova Killer" Hinton was one of the six known killings that terrorized the I-95 corridor in 1994 and earned Bowlesthe nickname of the "I-95 killer.". His profile is listed here. The 2019 crime rate in Jacksonville, FL is 367 (City-Data.com crime index), which is 1.4 times higher than the U.S. average. However, some problems remain with Tooles candidacy. He had epileptic seizures, he never learned to read, he dressed up as a girl, and he liked setting things on fire. And again Ottis was weeping, rubbing his nose, rubbing snot across mouth, saying, I dont believe that shit., You dont believe me? Terry said. Images taken from Mirror, News and Biography. Jacksonville Science Festival returns to the First Coast, William Wells letter to First Coast News in 2018. crime. Several mean-looking strangers were waiting for him there with their faces covered with burnt cork. It took another two months after Leach went missing before her body was found behind Suwannee River State Park. Danny Rolling, Ted Bundy and Aileen Wuornos, Samuel Little listens as he is sentenced to three consecutive terms of life in prison without parole for murdering three women in the late 1980s, in a Los Angeles courtroom Thursday, Sept. 25, 2014. The FBI says that while a manhunt was underway, Bundy killed two sorority girls and injured two others at Florida State University on Jan. 14, 1978. grew more brazen and he became less careful. The 2003 movie Monster starring Charlize Theron as Aileen is a biographical drama about her life. Ottis Toole was the life of the man called Ottis Toole, but he was also a symptom of the Springfield he grew up in. Calvary / Abyssinia Missionary Baptist Church (Grand Park), Sheps Discount and Salvage, Part Two: The Iron Lung, Small Red Shack at the City Limit Sign, U.S. 301, St. Gabriel Ethiopian Orthodox Church: Timkat, Epiphany, Westside Murder Map: Where George Ronnie York and James Latham Met Althea Ottavio and Patricia Anne Hewett, Westside Story: Adolescence (Early 1990s), Westside Story: From Nathan Bedford Forrest High School to the End of the Road, Westside: Apartment Complex, 103rd Street, Yellow Water Nuclear Weapons Storage Area, Annie Lytle Public School Number Four, Gilmore Street, Annie Lytle Public School Number Four, Gilmore Street, Addendum: Tim Gilmore is Still Here, Bold City Brewery and Intuition Ale Works: Growlers of Pale Ale in Old Warehouses by the Railroad Tracks, Feedback Loop Tomb, Shadows and Patterns down King Street and into North Riverside, Chimney Swifts at Riverside Christian Church, CoRK Arts District: Crystal Floyds Cabinet of Curiosities, CoRK Arts District: Olivier Flaires Studio, Cumberland Campus, Florida Junior College / Kent Campus, Florida State College at Jacksonville, End of the Streetcar Line, Patterns in the Brick Pavement, Aberdeen Street, Ernest and Copeland Streets (My Mothers First Apartment), Ernest Street to Willow Branch Park (Simultagnosia), Five Points Theatre / Riverside Theater (Sun-Ray Cinema), Five Points: Petersons Five and Dime Building, Five Points: Rain DogsBarstool for F. Kyle Marshall, aka DJ Chef Rocc, Fletcher Building (Ghosts of The Row and the May Street School of Architecture), Frank G. Slaughter, Medical Thrillers, and the Cleary-Dickert House, JASMYN (Jacksonville Area Sexual Minority Youth Network) House, Orange-State-Oil-Company-European-Street-Caf, Park and King, Park View Court Apartments / Wieselman Building, Purple Petunia Filling Station and Antique Bottle Collection, Ricker House / Queen Victoria / Lane House, River House / Riverside House / Rochester House-part-II, River House / Riverside House / Rochester House: Part I, Riverdale Inn / Brazil(e) House, Sugar Castle / Kelly House, Riverside High School (formerly Robert E. Lee), Part 1: The Girl Who Would Become My Mother, Riverside High School (formerly Robert E. Lee), Part 2: Ted Pappas Becoming Ted Pappas, Riverside High School (formerly Robert E. Lee), Part 3: History According to Vaudeville, Riverside High School (formerly Robert E. Lee), Part 4: Becoming Riverside High School, Riverside High School (formerly Robert E. Lee), Part 5: Coda The Prehistory of Friday Night Drums, rXr at Willow Branch and College, Death of a Crustpunk, Silvertown: My Mothers Early Childhood Home, Trump Campaign Office Update #5: The End Again (or, The Real End), Willowbranch Park and Cenotaph for Dogwood, Willowbranch Park and Library and Gay Pride, Woodlawn Baptist Church (My Mothers Early First Wedding), Banned Book Displays at Chamblin Bookmine and Chamblins Uptown, Free Bird & Midnight Rider & Confederate Flags & Mosh Pits, Georgia Savory and Air Potato, Cheryl after John Muir, Lovetts Grocery / Winn-Lovetts / Winn-Dixie & My Grandfather, National Association for the Advancement of White People, Jacksonville, Poor Penny Carson and Sweet Pea Johnson at Beach and Hodges Boulevards, Blanding Boulevard and 103rd Street, University Boulevard and Matthews Bridge / Arlington Expressway, Presidential Election, 1920 & Presidential Election, 2020 (Have Courage. please consider making a donation. The final victim, Ruth Mercado, was repeatedly raped at gunpoint in her own apartment and then killed. He was kind that way. I saw him shoot me. Witnesses said they heard gunshots about 1 a.m., and a Ford Mustang was seen leaving the area. Shirley Ann Bridgeford, another victim of Harvey Glatman aka The Lonely Hearts Killer. And a rapist. In the ten-year period during the 1980's, the state recorded 247 serial murders making Florida the third most dangerous state in the United States. Two others also died while she was watching them, according to the Capitol News Service. Bowles had an abusive childhood, was homeless, and earned money working as a prostitute. Engineer Richard Hawes, his wife, and two children were brutally murdered in the event that baffled people for years. Yes. Leslie Van Houten. READ MORE >>From 2011: William Wells, the Monster of Mayport, currently serving six life sentences, also facing another first-degree murder charge. Though the 1897 Marie Louise Gato murder trial was the most sensational the city had seen, Jacksonville owed a big part of its reputation throughout the next century to murder. We sell limited edition hand drawn serial killer shirts and horror apparel. Which way did you tell us you were going? Women swooned and fainted. to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really Theodore Robert Bundy was the archetype of the serial killer, the cunning psychopath whose disarming appearancehe was often called charming, handsome and intelligentconcealed a sadistic compulsion to killrepeatedlyfor sexual gratification.
Jacksonville, FL Crime Rates & Map - AreaVibes Now, according to law enforcement sources, he did -- two weeks ago, at Florida State Prison. He pulled the car over, never knowing he had just cornered a cunning and skilled mass murderer. Their confessions thrust the two men into the global spotlight as perhaps the most prolific serial killers in U.S. history. * July 4 th, 1930 was a different kind of Independence Day for J.J. Mendenhall. A former high school football player, Toboada put up a fight before both were. He confessed to derive sadistic pleasure in rape and murder. He got a seventh life sentence for murdering a fellow inmate at Florida State Prison in 2011. Frederick GOODE III, David 'Unruly passenger' from Jacksonville leads to diverted flight. You aint never seen a man hung by his neck in your lifetime. Later, when Hoffman showed Ottis the picture of Adams decapitated head, he asked him if this was the child he had abducted.
The 7 Scariest Florida Serial Killers | Serial Killer Shop No one would ever see them again. Bundy went to trial for the FSU deaths in Miami in 1979 and stood trial for Leach's death in Orlando in 1980. In Jacksonville you have a 1 in 29 chance of becoming a victim of crime. CHAVEZ, Michael Peter Notorious for disposing of the bodies in unusual poses, Long is considered to be a serial killer with a prominent modus operandi. The request was denied. Tommy Zeigler shot to death his wife, Eunice, her parents, Perry and Virginia Edwards and customer Charles Mays on Christmas Eve 1975 in the Zeigler family furniture store on Dillard Street in. Huh?, And Ottis sobbed hysterically and said, My fucking life! He didnt know the boys name or age or description, or where he was kidnapped. Look at me! The killings became known as the 'Donut Lake Murders' after the two bodies were found Feb. 10, 1982, in Donut Lake in suburban Jacksonville. The woman's family identified her as 31-year-old as Sharmeka Jackson. This information is not intended to be used as official crime data . Chapman was serving time for burglaries committed in Volusia County. His killings spanned over three states: Florida, Georgia, and Maryland. Haha, whats this guy luis talking about? One confessed serial killer with possible victim's in Florida may be the nation's deadliest. He notes in a postscript, You may remember me form the Mayport Mass Murder case of 2003.. Hes very impulsive. Rolling was arrested the following month while fleeing the attempted robbery of a Winn-Dixie store, and police noted he was wanted in Shreveport, where a triple murder he committed exhibited similarities to the Gainesville crimes. Remarkably, he escaped from custody not once, but twice; the first time from the second-story window of the courthouse law library during a recess in his 1977 preliminary hearing, and the second time that same year from his jail cell. Sonja Larson, 18, and Christina Powell, 17. Anyone with information on these possible cases is asked to contact the ViCAPat 800-634-4097. A juror named Bill Loos said hed examined the bullet in court, though the gun had gone missing, and from his knowledge of killing hogs, judged it a ricochet. The 1992 TV movie that resulted was one of several films about Aileen Wuornos, including two remarkable Nick Broomfield documentaries, and Monster, in which Charlize Therons portrayal of Wuornos won her an Oscar. A clipping from a 1997 issue of the Tampa Tribune. He remembered when he was a little boy, crouched amongst his siblings in his daddys old ramshackle truck, peeking over his hand and seeing a black body hanging from a tree.
17 Killer Kids Who Will Change the Way You See Children - The Lineup On the night of their deaths, Mendenhall said, Laura Mae had threatened to kill her daughter and then herself, that he had to use force, a vague phrase that opens further questions, to keep the mother from going to the river., And that night, Mary told him, I wish you would stay tonight. Jacksonville, Apalachicola, Quincy, and Key West are just a few of our favorites. Wells has not yet been charged. Alex Murdaugh Sentenced To Life In Prison For The Murder Of His Wife And Son. She called him Devils Child. Ottis Toole and his lover and partner-in-murder Henry Lee Lucas were part of an international Satanist organization. She took that chair and Pitzer sat down on the platform before the judges desk. HERNANDEZ-ALBERTO, Alexander The officers couldnt gain access to the room. Address: 5812 University Blvd W JACKSONVILLE FL Incident Date: 12-10-1997 Reporting Agency: Jacksonville SO Subject Information: Gender: MALE Race: WHITE About this case: On 12/10/1997, the victim was murdered at the Dairy Queen located at 5812 University Boulevard West, Jacksonville More about this case Best Image Available Jordan, Danny Eugene
10 Horrifying Serial Killers - Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, Ed Gein A key facet of the exploration into serial offenders has been the question of nature vs. nurture, and in Bundys case, it would almost seem that he was born evil. He told First Coast News he'd kill again. In the summer of 1990, the college town of Gainesville, Florida found itself in the grip of terror after five students were murdered in quick succession.
Top 10 Murder Houses In Los Angeles And Their Sinister - Listverse I really know myself that I really did kill Adam Walsh, he said. In the last decade, 73 Duval County children have been arrested in cases of murder and manslaughter. Rolling was arrested in Ocala on Sept. 7, 1990, on an unrelated burglary charge and as authorities were investigating, they were able to identify him as the Gainesville Ripper, a moniker developed based on the way the victims were bound, mutilated and posed. On Friday, July 22nd, a young woman was shot to death at a home on Prospect Street. J.J. Mendenhall was a citrus magnate. Dont tell me what you think. While the city with highest number of murders period? Love letters between Gato and Pitzer, read aloud in court, revealed that Pitzer fought a duel with a man named Domingo Herrera over Marie Louise.
Here Are The 10 Most Dangerous Towns In Florida To Live In And, by the time he arrived in Gainesville that summer, a multiple murderer. Just like that Waylon Jennings theme for The Dukes of Hazzard said: And Makin their way, the only way they know how, / Thats just a little bit more than the law will allow.. But Ottis couldnt remember what he had told Hoffman before, or if what he had told him was wrong or right. Paul John Knowles claimed to have murdered Mylette and Lillian Annette Anderson, two of those missing little girls, sisters aged six and 11, near their rural Northside home from which theyd been kidnapped. A rigid code of honor demands that when someone insults you, your own respect and identity is predicated on responding at least in kind, if not with greater violence.
'Monster of Mayport' reportedly continues killing two decades after Without a doubt, the most famous Florida serial killers include Danny Rolling, Ted Bundy, David Alan Gore, Gerard Schaefer, also known as "The Killer Cop," Aileen Wuornos, Bobby Joe Long, and "The Flat-Tire Murderer," who has remained unidentified since at least 1975. It seems Mendenhall always fell prey to womens manipulations that ended up benefiting him financially. I literally, literally defecated my pants. Most accurate 2021 crime rates for Jacksonville, FL. He was executedat Florida State Prison on Oct. 25, 2006.
Unsolved Cases in Florida Example video title will go here for this video. A man was observed walking toward the canal bank with a bucket in hand. The two became lovers and lived together at the home of Tooles parents, where Lucas befriended Tooles intellectually impaired niece, Becky Powell. Jacksonville, FL 32203 904-422-6078 - GM 904-766-8834 info@thefloridastar.com. There are a few random cases of women with a genteel knack for poisoning, but serial murdering black widows are a small club indeed. However, behind his handsome face lurked the twisted mind of a serial killer, and between the years of 1974 and 1978 Bundy kidnapped and murdered 30 young women in the U.S. In the early 1980s, Lucas traveled with Powell to California, where he ended up working for and living at the residence of 82-year-old Kate Rich. Growing up to be a drifter, panhandler, and prostitute, Toole received numerous accusations for crimes he may or may not have committed. They didnt intend to kill anybody. Four years after his release from state prison, J.J. Mendenhall was arrested in Jacksonville and tried for another double murder of mother and daughter, but this time a jury found him not guilty. Murderpedia has thousands of hours of work behind it. Floyd On Nov. 17, a Florida Highway Patrol Trooper named Charles Eugene Campbell recognized a car matching the description of one stolen from the most recent murder victim.